On 1/17/20, Rob Pike <robpike(a)gmail.com> wrote: [moving to COFF since this isn't specific to historic Unix] For applications (or groups of related applications) that are already distributed across multiple machines I'd say "cluster as a single system" definitely makes sense, but I still stand by what I said earlier about it not being relevant for things like workstations, or for server applications that are run on a single machine. I think clustering should be an optional subsystem, rather than something that is deeply integrated into the core of an OS. With an OS that has enough extensibiity, it should be possible to have an optional clustering subsystem without making it feel like an afterthought. That is what I am planning to do in UX/RT, the OS that I am writing. The "core supervisor" (seL4 microkernel + process server + low-level system library) will lack any built-in network support and will just have support for local file servers using microkernel IPC. The network stack, 9P client filesystem, 9P server, and clustering subsystem will all be separate regular processes. The 9P server will use regular read()/write()-like APIs rather than any special hooks (there will be read()/write()-like APIs that expose the message registers and shared buffer to make this more efficient), and similarly the 9P client filesystem will use the normal API for local filesystem servers (which will also use read()/write() to send messages). The clustering subsystem will work by intercepting process API calls and forwarding them to either the local process server or to a remote instance as appropriate. Since UX/RT will go even further than Plan 9 with its file-oriented architecture and make process APIs file-oriented, this will be transparent to applications. Basically, the way that the file-oriented process API will work is that every process will have a special "process server connection" file descriptor that carries all process server API calls over a minimalist form of RPC, and it will be possible to redirect this to an intermediary at process startup (of course, this redirection will be inherited by child processes automatically).