13 Jul
2024
13 Jul
'24
11:27 p.m.
On 7/13/24 10:25, Dan Cross wrote:
On Sat, Jul 13, 2024 at 5:57 AM Ralph
Corderoy<ralph(a)inputplus.co.uk> wrote:
> John and Paul wrote:
> Well, doesn't it depend on whether VAX MACRO kept the macros as
> high-level entities when translating them, or if it processed macros in
> the familiar way into instructions that sat at the same level as
> hand-written ‘assembler’. I don't think this thread has made that clear
> so far.
The DEC assemblers [sic] for the PDP-11 and VAX-11 did macro expansion
as text substitution.
AA-V027A-TC PDP-11 MACRO-11 Language Reference Manual
Section 7.1 (PDF file p 115, original document p 7-1) says
"Macro expansion is the insertion of the macro source lines into the
main program."
Note: This manual also discusses concatenation with macro arguments and
(on p 120 or p 7-6) macros that define other macros.
AA-D032B-TE VAX-11 MACRO Language Reference Manual
The beginning of chapter 6 (p 119 or p 6-1) says the same thing.
At least in those assemblers, macros were not inline procedures.
Google can find manuals for other assemblers. For even earlier history, see
https://github.com/PDP-10/its/issues/2032
http://www.bitsavers.org/pdf/mit/rle_pdp1/memos/PDP-1_MIDAS.pdf