[pdp7-unix] "original-commands" branch

Tom Everett tom at khubla.com
Mon Oct 28 05:07:16 AEST 2019


I'm on FreeBSD also, which is why I've tried to stick as possible to 
non-GNU make.


Phil Budne via pdp7-unix wrote on 2019-10-27 2:55 PM:
>> I'm not sure what level of Makefile tricks is desired here.  For your
>> consideration, I believe many rules like this:
>>
>> $(BINDIR)/sh: $(CMDSRC)/sh.s
>>          $(AS) $(ASARGS) -o $(BINDIR)/sh $(CMDSRC)/sh.s
>>
>> can be replaced by a single implicit rule such as:
>>
>> $(BINDIR)/%: $(CMDSRC)/%.s
>>          $(AS) $(ASARGS) -o $@ $^
>>
>> This wouldn't work for files built from several source files though.
> Thanks!  I had tried to figure out a way to make
>
> $(BINDIR)/sh: $(CMDSRC)/sh.s
>
> $(BINDIR)/thing: $(CMDSRC)/thing1.s $(CMDSRC)/thing2.s
>
> "do the right thing", but failed.
>
> Personally, I think less in a Makefile is easier to understand, up to
> a point (too much magic can be confusing as much as repeated and
> unnecessary noise), so (as always) it's a balancing act.
>
> But GNU make isn't really my thing (I still do work on FreeBSD where
> BSD make is the default), so I don't know all the tricks of the trade,
> and I GENERALLY try to stick to a portable subset. Plus I don't know
> which gmake constructs are "portable" (have existed forever) and which
> are not, so I was content to leave that judgement to someone else.
>
> Since there are sources in places other than CMDSRC (and it's possible
> that CMDSRC could be split up, say by adding GAMESRC), having an
> implicit rule with CMDSRC wired bothers me slightly.
>
> Something I'd like to eventually see would be to create the disk image
> with a "cold start" paper tape, and load the sources and minimal
> binaries via paper tape, and then regenerate all the binaries natively
> (either thru SimH scripting, or supplied "rc" files), so spending a
> lot of time crafting the ultimate Makefile isn't how I would spend my
> time!
> _______________________________________________
> pdp7-unix mailing list
> pdp7-unix at minnie.tuhs.org
> https://minnie.tuhs.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/pdp7-unix

-- 
Tom Everett
tom at khubla.com <mailto:tom at khubla.com>
<https://www.postbox-inc.com>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://minnie.tuhs.org/pipermail/pdp7-unix/attachments/20191027/820dac3c/attachment.html>


More information about the pdp7-unix mailing list