G. Branden Robinson:
That's why I think Norman has sussed it out accurately. LLMs are
fantastic bullshit generators in the Harry G. Frankfurt sense,[1]
wherein utterances are undertaken neither to enlighten nor to deceive,
but to construct a simulacrum of plausible discourse. BSing is a close
cousin to filibustering, where even plausibility is discarded, often for
the sake of running out a clock or impeding achievement of consensus.
====
That's exactly what I had in mind.
I think I had read Frankfurt's book before I first started
calling LLMs bullshit generators, but I can't remember for
sure. I don't plan to ask ChatGPT (which still, at least
sometimes, credits me with far greater contributions to Unix
than I have actually made).
Here's an interesting paper I stumbled across last week
which presents the case better than I could:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-024-09775-5
To link this back to actual Unix history (or something much
nearer that), I realized that `bullshit generator' was a
reasonable summary of what LLMs do after also realizing that
an LLM is pretty much just a much-fancier and better-automated
descendant of Mark V Shaney: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_V._Shaney
Norman Wilson
Toronto ON